Interview and Job Offer
Certain legal issues can arise at the interview and pre-employment stage. There are obligations under equality legislation to make sure that employment candidates are not excluded from employment because of gender, appearance, ethnicity, name, religion, accent etc.
An unsuccessful job applicant can make an application to an Employment Tribunal under anti-discrimination legislation. There is no cap on the compensation that the Tribunal may award if it finds that there has been unlawful discrimination.
The employment offer letter should be equivalent to an employment contract. It should provide details of the title, responsibilities, conditions of employment, probationary period and any pre-conditions required by a candidate e.g. references, employment permits etc.
Conditional Offers
A conditional offer of employment will often be appropriate. It may, for example, be desirable to make an offer subject to conditions such as the following:-
- passing a medical examination relevant to the employment; this must not discriminate against disabled people;
- passing a criminal records check;
- providing documents to prove they have the right to live and work in the United Kingdom;
- providing suitable references;
- completing a probationary period
If an offer is made subject to conditions, it is essential that the conditions are processed as soon as possible. If the offer is withdrawn, there is a risk that the conditions could be taken to be waived.
References and Medical Reports
There is no obligation on a current employer or previous employer to give a job reference. Employees generally do not have a right to see any job reference that may be given. However, employees may be able to obtain access to the reference if they take legal action or after they start to work with the new employer, through the Information Commissioners Office.
Requests for written references are best limited to specific information such as terms of employment, duties, the number of sick days, whether they were subject to disciplinary action, whether they were reliable, honest, hardworking and whether there are any reasons they should not be employed.
Health checks may raise issues under discrimination and data protection legislation. Health checks should only be requested when they are necessary.
If a medical report is required it is usual for the employer to pay. The candidate’s written consent is needed and he must be informed that he has a right to refuse. The candidate has a right to see the report before or after it is supplied, withhold consent to it being shown to the employer and request amendments. The doctor must keep it for 21 days before sending to the employer.
Verifying qualifications
A qualifications check can be made by consulting records of the relevant professional body or asking the candidate to bring certificates. A service for checking higher education qualifications is available from Expiron at their website. The Qualifications and Curriculum Authority (QCA) has a database setting out a wide range of qualifications. Vocational qualifications can be checked with the National Vocational Qualifications. Overseas academic qualifications can be checked and examined at the UK National Academic Recognition Information Centre (UKNARIC).
Criminal Records
Employers offering jobs involving regular contact with children or vulnerable adults may wish to verify the candidate’s criminal records. This can be done by the Criminal Records Bureau Disclosure Service (CRB). CRB offers employers who are registered with it either standard or enhanced disclosure.
Standard disclosure will list any spent or unspent convictions, cautions, warnings and reprimands at a national level. It can be made in connection with jobs involving working with children or vulnerable adults as well as some legal and financial jobs. A check will also show if requested, whether someone working in a childcare position is on either of the two Government lists of persons considered unfit for such work. If a person appearing on such list is applying for a childcare position, the police must be notified.
Enhanced disclosure also includes certain further relevant information. It will include acquittals. It can only be used for those whose work involves regularly caring for children or vulnerable adults.
There is legislation in England and Wales relating to spent convictions. Someone convicted of a criminal offence who does not receive any further convictions during the rehabilitation period becomes rehabilitated and their conviction is spent after a certain period of time. They must be treated as if the conviction had not happened. In this case, it is not possible to insist upon being told about a criminal offence that is spent. A conviction involving a prison sentence of 30 months or more, can never be spent.
A person must disclose all convictions, including spent ones if offered jobs in the following categories:-
- work with children or vulnerable adults;
- accountants and barristers;
- police;
- posts relating to the administration of the justice or financial regulation.
It is possible to withdraw a job offer or indeed to terminate a probation period where a pre-condition regarding criminal references etc. has not been complied with. However, the possibility of a breach of contract needs to be carefully considered. As in Ireland, very limited Unfair Dismissal rights apply during the first year.
Data Protection
The Data Protection Act provides that pre-employment checks can only be carried out where they are necessary and there is an objective point to the process. They should only be carried out in relation to the successful applicant and the applicant must know what checks are being made and how they will be carried out.
The checks must be made from an objective source and must use sources that will reveal relevant information. They must not rely on sources they do not trust. If the check reveals information that is not favourable, the applicant must be given a chance to explain it. If a third party is involved (e.g. a previous employer not listed as a referee) the applicant must be let know.
Candidate Selection
A job description should not contain requirements which are not directly related to the job. It is unlawful for a job advertisement to specify that an applicant must be a particular gender, race etc., unless this is a genuine occupational, qualification or requirement.
Advertisements must not imply that the candidate’s chance of success depends to any extent on not having a disability. The employee must make reasonable adjustments to accommodate disabled persons.
It is advisable not to use expressions such as “young and dynamic”, “just qualified” or a “minimum of ten years experience” as these may constitute age discrimination.
Application forms must be carefully vetted for compliance. Requests for age on an application form are not necessarily unlawful, but care should be taken to ensure that the information does not lead to unjustified discrimination.
It is legitimate to ascertain that an individual has a right to work in the United Kingdom, but this must be undertaken so as to avoid race discrimination. There are certain questions which should not be asked directly or indirectly in an interview. This includes whether a candidate is married, has a partner of the same sex, civil partnership or plans to have children. Information about sexual orientation should not be sought.
Information in connection with disability can only be requested to the extent that it is strictly relevant after any reasonable adjustment that is necessary. Reasonable adjustment in this context, refers to changes to accommodate the disability, be they physical or organisational, changes.
Tests must be non-discriminatory. A written test could be justified if good written English is necessary for the job. Where a disabled person applies, a reasonable adjustment will need to be made in relation to the test e.g. given more time, given appropriate facilities.
An employer can face a claim of unlawful discrimination if it picks a person for a job who is less qualified than another person who is female, black etc. It is permissible to offer a disabled applicant a job, even though they are not the best qualified. A recruitment process must always be capable of being justified, in case the matter is referred to an Industrial Tribunal.
